RJDiogenes wrote: ↑Tue Apr 09, 2024 7:52 pm
Given the success of Galaxy Quest and The Orville, are you a little surprised there isn't more sci-fi comedy?
I'm surprised those were successful.
In the past few years-- or several decades, at this point-- since people stopped maturing into adulthood, shows and movies have mostly needed to be all darkly cynical to be considered adult entertainment, because that's a child's view of adulthood. I'm rather encouraged by both
The Orville and
Strange New Worlds, because they might be a sign that this is turning around.
Interesting theory you have about how the darkness of TV series ties into adult maturation. I wonder if this explains why so many TV and movie heroes have turned into anti-heroes. An immature person can't identify with a mature hero, only an immature one. I'll have to ponder this. It makes some sense. No wonder you never liked
Seinfeld.
Maybe the rise of anti-heroes reflects a more cynical view of traditional authority figures and institutions, mirroring widespread skepticism and disillusionment with society. I believe this is called "postmodernism". In postmodernism, there's a rejection of the traditional narrative of the "hero's journey," where a morally upright protagonist defeats a clearly defined villain. Instead, postmodern narratives feature antiheroes who lack conventional heroic qualities, or who may even be morally ambiguous or flawed. Maybe people today harbor a postmodern skepticism towards traditional moral absolutes and grand narratives.
I've read that this kind of postmodern thinking began with JFK's assassination and was reinforced by the Watergate scandal and other major events that undermined confidence in society and heroism in general. What are your thoughts?
RJDiogenes wrote: ↑Tue Apr 09, 2024 7:52 pm
A mainstream comedy is just a comedy without SF or Fantasy elements, like
Mary Tyler Moore or
Three's Company. A genre comedy could be Sci-Fi, like
My Favorite Martian, or Fantasy, like
I Dream of Jeannie, or mock Horror, like
The Munsters. Even
Batman would qualify, since it's Fantasy of a kind.
Ahh. Thanks for clarifying. I never made these distinctions before, and they make sense.
RJDiogenes wrote: ↑Tue Apr 09, 2024 7:52 pm
So which mainstream comedy would you convert to genrehood?
Well, you know how much I loved (and still love) the old
Frasier series. Do you remember that the character of Daphne claimed to have psychic visions? No one took them seriously and these visions played an inconsequential role in the series. But what if Daphne's dreams and visions became more bizarre and were always prescient? She might inform Niles that she had a vision of him growing a third arm and a second head. Then sure enough, on that day, while in session with a client, he'd sprout an extra arm and head.
That would be a sci-fi version of
Frasier, but we might also enjoy a porn version
I think Jane Leeves in her prime was gorgeous, so let's see sex scenes with Niles and Daphne
Curiously, I have much less interest in seeing Frasier have sex with his girlfriends. I'm not sure why.
Do you have any ideas for mainstream comedy conversions?